Gotham FC forward Midge Purce called it "inexcusable" that the defending NWSL champions had to play their semifinal at the 5,000-seat Icahn Stadium, after her team lost 2-1 to the Kansas City Current on Sunday.
The NWSL moved Sunday's semifinal to Icahn Stadium on Randall's Island because of poor field conditions at Gotham's usual home, Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey. Icahn Stadium is mostly used for amateur events and has a track running around the soccer field.
Purce said the field was never an excuse for the result. "I want to be really clear and direct in saying that, in these types of situations, the field is never an excuse," she said. "We lost today because we weren't the better team."
She went on to say the situation was still inexcusable and a bad look for everyone involved, adding that the league is supposed to be one of the best in the world and that Gotham wanted to play in front of their fans at Sports Illustrated Stadium after earning that right throughout the season. She maintained, however, that the venue change had no effect on the team's performance.
Players from Gotham and the Seattle Reign had already described the Sports Illustrated Stadium field as "atrocious" following last week's quarterfinals. Those concerns led Gotham and the NWSL to relocate the semifinal after the league and the New York Red Bulls, who operate the stadium, could not agree on how to fix the field in time.
Gotham head coach Juan Carlos Amoros said the switch to Icahn Stadium was "also part of the sadness" surrounding the team, adding that they would never know what might have happened at Sports Illustrated Stadium, where Gotham had not lost in its previous 13 matches there. He said the situation at the other semifinal venue in Washington, D.C., on Saturday had also contributed to what he called a sad week, and that the league deserves better.
That other semifinal, played at Audi Field in Washington, featured American football field markings because of a scheduling conflict with an NCAA Division III football game.
Kansas City Current players were also unhappy with the change. The Current were the first NWSL team to build their own stadium and were the only team in this year's playoff field to own their venue. Current defender Kayla Sharples said the day before the match that it had been disappointing and frustrating that headlines leading into the semifinal focused on poor field quality and stadium availability rather than the game itself, saying that would not happen in the men's game and that players reaching the pinnacle of their careers deserve a stage that matches that achievement.
Lines of fans stretched hundreds of feet from Icahn Stadium's single entry point ahead of kickoff, though nearly all made it inside in time. With limited transit options to the venue, Gotham FC paid for extra ferries and buses to Randall's Island, and New York City added extra bus service on routes serving the area. Dozens of Kansas City Current family and friends traveled with the team on a charter flight to support them in the semifinal.
Audi Field is set to host the NWSL Championship on Saturday, a week after hosting the NWSL and American football doubleheader.
