Haddington Athletic host Cumbernauld Colts in the Scottish FA Cup. Colts have had a genuinely mixed year, stacking decent away wins alongside some heavy beatings.
Haddington's own form is much harder to read, with only a couple of results on file for them. That imbalance in evidence is worth keeping in mind before drawing any conclusions here.
Analysis updated .
Compare bookmakers
Two very different form pictures
Cumbernauld Colts have a decent-sized sample to judge them by, 20 matches across the Lowland League and Challenge Cup, and it's a mixed bag. Five wins, six draws and nine losses, with 34 goals scored but 45 conceded, points to a side that can score but also leaks goals fairly often. Recent weeks alone have brought a 0-4 defeat to St Mirren's under-21s and a 0-3 loss to Kelty Hearts, but also tidier away wins like 2-1 at Albion Rovers and 1-0 at Auchinleck Talbot.
Haddington Athletic: 2 completed matches; Cumbernauld Colts: 20 completed matches.
| League | Home | Away | Date | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Friendlies Clubs | Haddington Athletic | Gala Fairydean Rovers | 04.07.2026 | 0-2 |
| FA Cup | Auchinleck Talbot | Haddington Athletic | 30.08.2025 | 4-0 |
| League | Home | Away | Date | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Challenge Cup | Cumbernauld Colts | St. Mirren U21 | 26.09.2026 | 2-4 |
| Challenge Cup | Stirling Albion | Cumbernauld Colts | 22.09.2026 | 1-1 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Albion Rovers | Cumbernauld Colts | 19.09.2026 | 2-1 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Cumbernauld Colts | Gretna 2008 | 15.09.2026 | 3-2 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Cumbernauld Colts | Johnstone Burgh | 12.09.2026 | 4-4 |
| Challenge Cup | Cumbernauld Colts | Kelty Hearts | 08.09.2026 | 0-3 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Troon FC | Cumbernauld Colts | 29.08.2026 | 1-3 |
| Challenge Cup | Cumbernauld Colts | Kilmarnock II | 25.08.2026 | 1-1 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Cumbernauld Colts | Dalbeattie Star | 22.08.2026 | 2-2 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Gretna 2008 | Cumbernauld Colts | 15.08.2026 | 3-3 |
Haddington Athletic's sample is tiny by comparison, just two matches on record. A 0-2 friendly defeat to Gala Fairydean Rovers and a 4-0 loss away to Auchinleck Talbot in the FA Cup, the latter over a year old now. Both were defeats without a goal scored, but two matches, one of them long past, can't really tell us much about where they stand now.

What might shape the tie
Cumbernauld Colts' defensive record, 45 conceded across 20 games, suggests they can be got at, which might give Haddington something to work with regardless of their own patchy data. At the same time, Colts have shown in bursts that they can score goals too, so it wouldn't be a shock if this one opened up rather than staying tight.
With so little recent evidence for Haddington against comparable opposition, it's hard to say how they'll cope with a side that's had a rockier but more varied season. Cup ties like this often come down to which team's inconsistencies show up on the day.
Between a leaky but occasionally potent away side and a home team we barely have recent data on, there isn't enough here to build a confident case either way.
With no market on offer and the evidence this thin, sitting this one out feels like the sensible call rather than forcing an angle that isn't really there.
