Buxton host South Shields in the FA Cup. Both sides have been finding good form domestically over the past month, with wins stacking up at both ends of the draw.
This tie follows straight on from cup wins for both clubs in the previous round, so we've got two teams with confidence high heading into this one. How that form carries over against a familiar rival is the interesting bit.
Analysis updated .
Compare bookmakers
Recent form for both sides
Buxton have been the busier winners lately, taking 13 of their last 20 matches with only five defeats. There's a run of five straight wins in there, including a 5-0 thumping of Brackley Town and a 4-0 win away at Morecambe, before a loss to Hebburn Town broke the sequence.
Buxton: 20 completed matches; South Shields: 20 completed matches.
Buxton
- Win
- 60% 12 / 20
- Draw
- 10% 2 / 20
- Loss
- 30% 6 / 20
- Scored
- 39
- Conceded
- 28
- Difference
- +11
South Shields
- Win
- 55% 11 / 20
- Draw
- 20% 4 / 20
- Loss
- 25% 5 / 20
- Scored
- 37
- Conceded
- 22
- Difference
- +15
| League | Home | Away | Date | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| National League - North | South Shields | Buxton | 26.09.2026 | 4-0 |
| FA Cup | Buxton | Ashton United | 19.09.2026 | 1-0 |
| National League - North | Buxton | Chester | 12.09.2026 | 3-1 |
| National League - North | Buxton | Brackley Town | 08.09.2026 | 5-0 |
| National League - North | Morecambe | Buxton | 05.09.2026 | 4-0 |
| National League - North | Buxton | Merthyr Town | 31.08.2026 | 2-1 |
| National League - North | Oxford City | Buxton | 28.08.2026 | 2-3 |
| National League - North | Buxton | Hebburn Town | 22.08.2026 | 1-2 |
| National League - North | Bedford Town | Buxton | 18.08.2026 | 2-1 |
| National League - North | Southport | Buxton | 15.08.2026 | 1-1 |
| League | Home | Away | Date | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| National League - North | South Shields | Buxton | 26.09.2026 | 4-0 |
| FA Cup | South Shields | Witton Albion | 19.09.2026 | 7-0 |
| National League - North | Hereford | South Shields | 12.09.2026 | 6-0 |
| National League - North | South Shields | Marine | 08.09.2026 | 2-1 |
| National League - North | Hednesford Town | South Shields | 05.09.2026 | 0-1 |
| National League - North | South Shields | Spalding United | 31.08.2026 | 1-1 |
| National League - North | South Shields | Merthyr Town | 22.08.2026 | 1-1 |
| National League - North | Morecambe | South Shields | 18.08.2026 | 0-1 |
| National League - North | South Shields | Chorley | 15.08.2026 | 2-1 |
| National League - North | Scarborough Athletic | South Shields | 08.08.2026 | 0-1 |
South Shields have also had some big scorelines recently, including a 7-0 FA Cup win over Witton Albion and a 6-0 away league win at Hereford. But their overall record is a bit more mixed, with 10 wins, 5 draws and 5 losses from 20, and three defeats in their last six outings.
Both teams have shown they can score heavily, but South Shields have also been more prone to dropping points than Buxton lately.
Comparative Team Statistics: Buxton vs South Shields

A tight recent history
These two have met 11 times since 2019, and it's been fairly even. The most recent meeting, back in May, saw Buxton win 1-0 at home. Before that came a 1-1 draw in January and a 2-2 draw at South Shields the previous August.
| League | Home | Away | Date | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| National League - North | South Shields | Buxton | 26.09.2026 | 4-0 |
| National League - North | South Shields | Buxton | 02.05.2026 | 1-0 |
| National League - North | Buxton | South Shields | 03.01.2026 | 1-1 |
| National League - North | South Shields | Buxton | 30.08.2025 | 2-2 |
| National League - North | Buxton | South Shields | 11.02.2025 | 1-0 |
| National League - North | South Shields | Buxton | 03.09.2024 | 1-0 |
| National League - North | Buxton | South Shields | 16.03.2024 | 0-2 |
| National League - North | South Shields | Buxton | 07.11.2023 | 1-0 |
| Non League Premier - Northern | Buxton | South Shields | 05.02.2022 | 2-2 |
| Non League Premier - Northern | South Shields | Buxton | 23.10.2021 | 0-1 |
Across the wider record there's been very little to separate them, with plenty of draws and one-goal margins rather than one side dominating.
The head-to-head record points to a close contest rather than another high-scoring afternoon.

How this cup tie could play out
Both sides go into this off the back of cup wins, though Buxton's was a tighter 1-0 over Ashton United while South Shields ran up a 7-0 scoreline against Witton Albion. That gap doesn't tell us much on its own since we don't know how strong that opposition was.
Given the closeness of their head-to-head history and the goals both teams have shown they can score domestically, this looks like it could go either way. It wouldn't be a surprise to see goals, but it also wouldn't be a shock if it came down to a single moment.
Squad lists and player details
Squad and player details
| Name | Country | Age | Position | Height | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| J. Wright | England | 30 | Attacker | 176 cm | n/a |
| E. McKeown | England | 27 | Attacker | 190 cm | n/a |
| J. Burrow | England | 34 | Attacker | 175 cm | 76 kg |
| N. Wood | England | n/a | Midfielder | n/a | n/a |
| S. Boden | England | 36 | Attacker | 180 cm | 70 kg |
| C. Weston | England | 39 | Midfielder | 180 cm | 74 kg |
| O. Sherwood | England | n/a | Midfielder | n/a | n/a |
| S. Osborne | England | 27 | Midfielder | 177 cm | 65 kg |
| J. McCourt | England | 31 | Midfielder | 178 cm | 68 kg |
| M. Goodridge | England | 27 | Midfielder | 180 cm | n/a |
| W. Clarke | England | 28 | Midfielder | 172 cm | n/a |
| J. Barnett | England | 26 | Midfielder | 178 cm | 83 kg |
| M. Waters | England | 28 | Defender | 178 cm | 68 kg |
| L. Shiels | England | 37 | Defender | n/a | n/a |
| R. Qualter | England | 34 | Defender | 188 cm | n/a |
| S. Minihan | England | 32 | Defender | 185 cm | 74 kg |
| A. Livingstone | Scotland | 28 | Defender | 180 cm | 71 kg |
| M. Hunt | England | 27 | Defender | 198 cm | 88 kg |
| C. Brown | England | 35 | Defender | 176 cm | 69 kg |
| J. Young | England | 24 | Goalkeeper | n/a | n/a |
| Name | Country | Age | Position | Height | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| J. Sheik | England | 21 | Goalkeeper | n/a | n/a |
| C. Sykes | England | 24 | Defender | n/a | n/a |
| D. Morse | England | 32 | Defender | 190 | n/a |
| R. Tinkler | England | 30 | Defender | 183 | n/a |
| Oliver Bainbridge | England | 21 | Defender | n/a | n/a |
| D. Dodds | England | 25 | Midfielder | n/a | n/a |
| L. Woolston | England | 21 | Midfielder | n/a | n/a |
| W. Jenkins | England | 24 | Midfielder | 176 | n/a |
| C. Scott | England | 27 | Midfielder | 178 | 75 |
| P. Blackett | England | 28 | Attacker | 171 | n/a |
| D. Carson | England | 31 | Midfielder | 178 | 69 |
| D. Ward | England | 29 | Midfielder | 179 | n/a |
| Sean McGurk | England | 23 | Attacker | 179 | n/a |
| Todd Alcock | England | 21 | Midfielder | n/a | n/a |
With no market to weigh up and a head-to-head record that's stayed close for years, there isn't a clear enough edge here to back with confidence.
Both teams look capable of scoring goals and both have shown they can also be beaten, so this feels like one to watch unfold rather than force a view on.
