Newton Stewart host Johnstone Burgh in the Scottish FA Cup. Both sides have had a bit of a mixed few months, with neither settling into any real rhythm.
The interesting bit here is that these two already met last month in the league, and it didn't go the way recent home form would suggest. That's worth keeping in mind before assuming anything about how this one plays out.
Analysis updated .
Compare bookmakers
Two sides going in different directions at home and away
Newton Stewart's home matches this year have been tough watching if you support them. One win in nine, with 35 goals conceded in that span, including a 5-1 home defeat to Troon and a 9-0 hammering away at Auchinleck Talbot. There's a 5-0 win over Cumnock Juniors in there too, so it's not been total misery, but the overall shape is pretty grim defensively.
Newton Stewart: 9 completed matches; Johnstone Burgh: 14 completed matches.
Newton Stewart
- Win
- 11.1% 1 / 9
- Draw
- 11.1% 1 / 9
- Loss
- 77.8% 7 / 9
- Scored
- 10
- Conceded
- 35
- Difference
- -25
Johnstone Burgh
- Win
- 42.9% 6 / 14
- Draw
- 21.4% 3 / 14
- Loss
- 35.7% 5 / 14
- Scored
- 29
- Conceded
- 24
- Difference
- +5
| League | Home | Away | Date | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Football League - Lowland League | Newton Stewart | Dalbeattie Star | 19.09.2026 | 2-1 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Newton Stewart | Troon FC | 12.09.2026 | 1-5 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Cumnock Juniors | Newton Stewart | 29.08.2026 | 5-0 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Johnstone Burgh | Newton Stewart | 22.08.2026 | 3-2 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Newton Stewart | Pollok | 08.08.2026 | 2-2 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Newton Stewart | Auchinleck Talbot | 01.08.2026 | 0-9 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Gretna 2008 | Newton Stewart | 29.07.2026 | 3-0 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Clydebank | Newton Stewart | 25.07.2026 | 4-2 |
| FA Cup | Glasgow University | Newton Stewart | 30.08.2025 | 3-1 |
| League | Home | Away | Date | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Football League - Lowland League | Johnstone Burgh | Renfrew | 26.09.2026 | 3-2 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Largs Thistle | Johnstone Burgh | 23.09.2026 | 1-0 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Troon FC | Johnstone Burgh | 16.09.2026 | 1-2 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Cumbernauld Colts | Johnstone Burgh | 12.09.2026 | 4-4 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Johnstone Burgh | Dalbeattie Star | 29.08.2026 | 4-0 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Johnstone Burgh | Newton Stewart | 22.08.2026 | 3-2 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Pollok | Johnstone Burgh | 19.08.2026 | 3-1 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Johnstone Burgh | Albion Rovers | 08.08.2026 | 2-2 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Celtic II | Johnstone Burgh | 01.08.2026 | 1-1 |
| Football League - Lowland League | Johnstone Burgh | Troon FC | 29.07.2026 | 2-0 |
Johnstone Burgh's away form is more balanced by comparison. Five wins, three draws and five losses from thirteen games, with 26 scored and 22 conceded, so goals tend to arrive whichever way this side lines up. Their last two away trips were both defeats though, a 1-0 loss to Largs Thistle and a 2-1 loss to Troon, so they're not exactly flying into this one either.
Newton Stewart's home defensive numbers look shaky against a side that's scored fairly freely on the road this season.
They've already played this month
There's only one meeting on record between these two, and it's a recent one. Newton Stewart won 3-2 at home against Johnstone Burgh back in August, right in the middle of an otherwise poor home run.
| League | Home | Away | Date | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Football League - Lowland League | Johnstone Burgh | Newton Stewart | 22.08.2026 | 3-2 |
That result sits oddly next to everything else in Newton Stewart's home form, where they've mostly struggled. It suggests they can raise their level against this particular opponent, even if their general home form doesn't inspire confidence.
One data point isn't a pattern, but it does show Newton Stewart aren't hopeless against this specific team.

A cup tie between two inconsistent sides
This is a knockout match, and both sides arrive with question marks. Newton Stewart's home numbers point to problems, particularly at the back, but their most recent result against this exact opponent bucks that trend entirely. Johnstone Burgh have goals in them but have dropped their last two away games, so their form's cooled a touch as well.
With such a small home sample for Newton Stewart, and Johnstone Burgh's away form swinging between comfortable wins and losses, this looks like one of those matches that could go either way rather than following a clear script.
There's enough here to describe the picture but not enough to back a specific side with confidence. Newton Stewart's home numbers are worrying, yet their one meeting with Johnstone Burgh this season went the other way entirely.
Without a market to weigh up, and with both teams showing patchy recent form, this is one to watch rather than back.
