Chicago Fire vs New York City FC Prediction & Betting Tips

Last updated 26 Sep 2026
Chicago Fire
Chicago Fire
USA MLS
10.10.2026    19:30
00
days
00
hours
00
min
00
sec
Bet Now
W1
C: 1.75
X
C: 3.9
W2
C: 3.9
New York City FC
New York City FC

Chicago Fire host New York City FC in Major League Soccer. Both clubs have had up-and-down campaigns, blowing hot in some weeks and going cold in others.

Chicago sit comfortably above City in the table, yet the two clubs have swapped some entertaining results whenever they've met recently. That contrast between league position and head-to-head history is worth picking apart before deciding what to make of this one.

Analysis updated .

Compare bookmakers

№
Bookmaker
Rating
Bonus Offer
Promo Code
Secure link
1
Mybookie logo.
5 \ 5
Up TO $200
First Deposit Bonus
Live Odds
Deposit Options and Fees
Access in the US
NO CODE
Visit
Join Mybookie and Receive Up to $200 as a First Deposit Bonus! Secure a 100% match on your initial deposit, up to the maximum bonus amount. To access and withdraw your bonus, satisfy specific wagering requirements. See below for full T&C;'s, 18+, BeGambleAware.org
2
Xbet logo.
4.9 \ 5
Up to $500 + $10 Casino Chips
First Deposit Bonus
Range of Sports
Legality and Accessibility
Payout Methods and Times
NO CODE
Visit
Up to $500 First Deposit Bonus Plus a $10 Casino Chip! Enjoy a 100% match on your first deposit up to the maximum bonus amount. To release and withdraw your bonus, adhere to the specific wagering requirements. See below for full T&C;'s, 18+, BeGambleAware.org
3
Busr logo.
4.8 \ 5
100% Up TO $2500
Welcome Bonus
Availability Across Most States
Deposit Options
Customer Service
NO CODE
Visit
Up to $2500! Receive a 100% bonus on your initial deposit, up to the maximum bonus value. To access and withdraw your bonus, you need to fulfill specific wagering requirements. See below for full T&C;'s, 18+, BeGambleAware.org

Recent form: goals at both ends, but different rhythms

Chicago Fire have won 9 of their last 20 matches across all competitions, drawing 4 and losing 7, scoring 36 and conceding 34 along the way. That's a side that scores freely but also leaks goals fairly often.

What could your bet return?

1
Chicago Fire to win
Mybookie logo.
Odds1.75
Potential return£35.00Bet Now
X
Draw
Mybookie logo.
Odds3.9
Potential return£78.00Bet Now
2
New York City FC to win
Mybookie logo.
Odds3.9
Potential return£78.00Bet Now

Potential returns include your stake. Odds may change.

Chicago Fire: 20 completed matches; New York City FC: 20 completed matches.

Chicago Fire

20 matches
Win
45% 9 / 20
Draw
20% 4 / 20
Loss
35% 7 / 20
Scored
36
Conceded
34
Difference
+2

New York City FC

20 matches
Win
30% 6 / 20
Draw
25% 5 / 20
Loss
45% 9 / 20
Scored
24
Conceded
23
Difference
+1
Chicago Fire
League Home Away Date Score
Major League Soccer Nashville SC Chicago Fire 20.09.2026 3-0
Major League Soccer Chicago Fire New England Revolution 14.09.2026 1-2
Major League Soccer Chicago Fire Inter Miami 10.09.2026 1-1
Major League Soccer Toronto FC Chicago Fire 06.09.2026 4-4
Major League Soccer Seattle Sounders Chicago Fire 29.08.2026 2-2
Leagues Cup Monterrey Chicago Fire 26.08.2026 2-1
Major League Soccer New York Red Bulls Chicago Fire 23.08.2026 1-1
Major League Soccer Orlando City SC Chicago Fire 20.08.2026 1-2
Major League Soccer Chicago Fire Portland Timbers 17.08.2026 2-1
Leagues Cup Cruz Azul Chicago Fire 14.08.2026 1-2
Load more
New York City FC
League Home Away Date Score
Major League Soccer New York City FC New York Red Bulls 19.09.2026 0-1
Major League Soccer Real Salt Lake New York City FC 13.09.2026 0-2
Major League Soccer New York City FC New England Revolution 10.09.2026 1-2
Major League Soccer New York City FC Nashville SC 05.09.2026 0-0
Major League Soccer Toronto FC New York City FC 30.08.2026 1-1
Major League Soccer New England Revolution New York City FC 23.08.2026 1-1
Major League Soccer FC Cincinnati New York City FC 20.08.2026 2-1
Major League Soccer New York City FC Philadelphia Union 17.08.2026 2-3
Leagues Cup New York City FC Necaxa 14.08.2026 1-2
Leagues Cup Cruz Azul New York City FC 10.08.2026 2-1
Load more

New York City FC have had a rougher recent run, winning just 6 of 20, losing 9, with a tighter goal difference of 24 for and 23 against. It points to a team involved in low-scoring, scrappier games rather than one running up big scorelines.

Chicago's extra firepower could be an asset at home, but their leaky defence means City won't necessarily be shut out either.

Head-to-head: City have had the better of it lately

Looking at the last five meetings between these two, New York City FC have won three, including a 3-1 win back in July, with the other two ending level. Chicago haven't actually beaten City in that recent stretch, despite generally sitting higher in the standings during that period.

Head 2 Head
League Home Away Date Score
Major League Soccer New York City FC Chicago Fire 26.07.2026 3-1
Major League Soccer Chicago Fire New York City FC 14.09.2025 1-3
Major League Soccer New York City FC Chicago Fire 25.05.2025 3-1
Major League Soccer New York City FC Chicago Fire 25.08.2024 2-2
Major League Soccer Chicago Fire New York City FC 14.07.2024 0-0
Major League Soccer New York City FC Chicago Fire 23.10.2023 1-0
Major League Soccer Chicago Fire New York City FC 05.03.2023 1-1
Major League Soccer Chicago Fire New York City FC 22.08.2022 0-2
Major League Soccer New York City FC Chicago Fire 23.05.2022 1-0
Major League Soccer New York City FC Chicago Fire 28.10.2021 1-0
Load more

Go back further and the head-to-head is more even, spanning several seasons and different competitions, so it's not something to lean on too heavily. Still, the recent trend is a mild point in City's favour.

League table: Fire well ahead on paper

Chicago Fire are fifth with 39 points from 25 matches, built on 11 wins, 6 draws and 8 losses. New York City FC are down in tenth with 32 points from 26 games, having won just 8, drawn 8 and lost 10.

№ Team Played Win Draw Loss GF/GA Points
Eastern Conference
1 Nashville SC 26 17 6 3 53/21 57
2 New England Revolution 26 14 4 8 45/33 46
3 Inter Miami 26 12 10 4 63/48 46
4 Charlotte 26 12 7 7 47/37 43
5 Chicago Fire 25 11 6 8 45/38 39
6 Philadelphia Union 26 10 6 10 50/42 36
7 Orlando City SC 26 10 4 12 46/60 34
8 New York Red Bulls 26 9 6 11 34/48 33
9 FC Cincinnati 25 8 9 8 54/61 33
10 New York City FC 26 8 8 10 39/34 32
11 DC United 25 6 11 8 31/39 29
12 Toronto FC 26 6 11 9 39/49 29
13 Columbus Crew 26 7 5 14 37/42 26
14 Atlanta United FC 26 7 5 14 30/43 26
15 CF Montreal 26 5 6 15 31/53 21

That's a clear gap in the standings, and it lines up with Chicago's slightly better recent form figures too.

The table backs Chicago as the stronger side this season, even if their recent head-to-head record against City tells a different story.

Team news: goals up top, fitness concerns in defence

Hugo Cuypers has been prolific for Chicago, with 13 goals in just 11 matches, but he's one of several Fire players carrying knocks, alongside Bamba, Radojevic, Shokalook and Mueller. That's a fairly lengthy list of fitness question marks heading into this one.

Chicago Fire:
Best scorers:
H. Cuypers - 13
Best assist providers:
P. Zinckernagel - 8
Penalty cards:
T. D'Avilla red card x 7
Injury list:
J. Bamba
V. Radojevic
J. Shokalook
H. Cuypers
C. Mueller
L. Barroso
N. Allen
C. Brady
P. Dithejane
R. Lewandowski
R. Lod
M. Mbokazi
A. Mekvabishvili
A. Franco
New York City FC:
Best scorers:
N. Fernández Mercau - 15
Best assist providers:
A. Ojeda - 8
Penalty cards:
N. Fernández Mercau red card x 8
Injury list:
D. Baiera
A. Farnos
M. Freese
T. Gray
M. Ilenic
M. Moralez
A. O'Neill
K. Parks
Talles Magno
K. Trewin

New York City's main scoring threat remains Fernández Mercau with 15 goals in 25 games, supported by Ojeda's creativity. City also have a number of players flagged for various issues, including Baiera, Moralez and Talles Magno, though none of that confirms who will actually be missing come matchday.

Worth checking the matchday squads closer to kickoff rather than assuming any of these names are definitely out.

Match odds and squad lists
MATCH RESULT (1x2)
W1: 1.75
Х: 3.9
W2: 3.9
Handicap
Chicago Fire
New York City FC
Handicap (-3.5): 10.00
Handicap (-3.5): 1.03
Handicap (-2.75): 7.20
Handicap (-2.75): 1.03
Handicap (-2.5): 5.90
Handicap (-2.5): 1.13
Handicap (-2.25): 5.50
Handicap (-2.25): 1.15
Handicap (-2): 5.00
Handicap (-2): 1.17
Handicap (-1.75): 3.55
Handicap (-1.75): 1.27
Handicap (-1.5): 3.00
Handicap (-1.5): 1.38
Handicap (-1.25): 2.60
Handicap (-1.25): 1.48
Handicap (-1): 2.35
Handicap (-1): 1.58
Handicap (-0.75): 2.00
Handicap (-0.75): 1.80
Handicap (-0.5): 1.78
Handicap (-0.5): 2.02
Handicap (-0.25): 1.58
Handicap (-0.25): 2.35
Handicap (0): 1.38
Handicap (0): 3.00
Handicap (0.25): 1.30
Handicap (0.25): 3.45
Handicap (0.5): 1.26
Handicap (0.5): 3.70
Handicap (0.75): 1.18
Handicap (0.75): 4.80
Handicap (1): 1.03
Handicap (1): 7.60
Handicap (1.5): 1.01
Handicap (1.5): 8.60
Handicap (2.5): 1.01
Handicap (2.5): 13.00
Total
Over
Under
Over (0.5): 1.02
Under (0.5): 17.00
Over (1.5): 1.17
Under (1.5): 5.00
Over (1.75): 1.13
Under (1.75): 4.50
Over (2): 1.17
Under (2): 4.00
Over (2.25): 1.32
Under (2.25): 2.88
Over (2.5): 1.53
Under (2.5): 2.40
Over (2.75): 1.58
Under (2.75): 2.12
Over (3): 1.77
Under (3): 1.87
Over (3.25): 2.01
Under (3.25): 1.68
Over (3.5): 2.25
Under (3.5): 1.57
Over (3.75): 2.60
Under (3.75): 1.41
Over (4): 3.20
Under (4): 1.27
Over (4.25): 3.50
Under (4.25): 1.22
Over (4.5): 4.00
Under (4.5): 1.22
Over (4.75): 4.80
Under (4.75): 1.11
Over (5): 6.60
Under (5): 1.05
Over (5.25): 7.00
Under (5.25): 1.04
Over (5.5): 8.00
Under (5.5): 1.08
Over (6.5): 17.00
Under (6.5): 1.02
Over (7.5): 29.00
Under (7.5): 1.01
More odds

Squad and player details

Chicago Fire
Name Country Age Position Height Weight
R. Lewandowski Poland 38 Attacker 186 81
J. Bamba Côte d'Ivoire 30 Attacker 175 72
H. Cuypers Belgium 29 Attacker 185 75
P. Zinckernagel Denmark 31 Attacker 175 70
R. Lod Finland 33 Midfielder 181 86
A. Salétros Sweden 30 Midfielder 183 71
M. Haile-Selassie Switzerland 27 Midfielder 177 68
J. Elliott England 31 Defender 198 83
C. Mueller USA 30 Attacker 175 75
J. Cohen USA 34 Goalkeeper 185 79
J. Waterman Canada 30 Defender 185 77
A. Gutman USA 30 Defender 178 72
S. Rogers USA 27 Defender 193 86
J. Gal USA 33 Goalkeeper 187 n/a
J. Gómez USA 25 Attacker 178 75
A. Mekvabishvili Georgia 25 Midfielder 174 68
M. Pineda USA 28 Defender 185 78
J. Dean USA 29 Defender 173 72
C. Brady USA 22 Goalkeeper 191 77
N. Allen USA 22 Defender 175 66
New York City FC
Name Country Age Position Height Weight
H. Wolf Austria 27 Attacker 179 69
A. O'Neill Australia 28 Midfielder 180 79
A. Perea USA 25 Midfielder 182 72
Raul Gustavo Brazil 27 Defender n/a n/a
S. Tanasijević Serbia 29 Defender 183 73
Thiago Martins Brazil 31 Defender 185 78
M. Freese USA 28 Goalkeeper 190 88
K. Parks USA 29 Midfielder 191 81
M. Moralez Argentina 39 Midfielder 160 52
J. Sands USA 26 Defender 186 84
G. Ranjitsingh Trinidad and Tobago 33 Goalkeeper 188 91
Talles Magno Brazil 24 Attacker 185 70
N. Fernández Mercau Argentina 26 Midfielder 172 71
A. Martínez Costa Rica 27 Attacker 177 72
T. Romero El Salvador 25 Goalkeeper 188 86
K. O'Toole USA 27 Midfielder 178 68
K. Trewin Australia 25 Defender n/a n/a
T. Gray Jamaica 24 Defender 180 74
B. Traoré Côte d'Ivoire 23 Attacker 172 68
M. Ilenič Slovenia 21 Defender 178 71

Put together, this looks like a genuinely competitive match rather than a clear mismatch. Chicago's table position points one way, City's recent head-to-head form points another, and the fitness list adds another layer of uncertainty.

With no strong market lean available to weigh against those mixed signals, it's sensible to leave this one alone rather than force a pick.

Match result odds

Mybookie logo.
Chicago Fire to win
1.75
Bet Now
Mybookie logo.
Draw
3.9
Bet Now
Mybookie logo.
New York City FC to win
3.9
Bet Now

Who will win?


Chicago Fire (0%)
Draw (0%)
New York City FC (0%)
Vitory Santos
Author
Last updated: September 2026
Random Tips